The Rock And Roll O Logues
short stories about music
10/31/05
October 29 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, The Mae Shi – Bowery Ballroom, New York NY
October 28 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Fuel Rocket Club, Collis Center, Dartmouth College, Hanover NH
I napped the afternoon away and around 6pm went to where the show was to be held only to find no one there and a sign stating that doors would open at 9pm. Fortunately the college maintains a bar just a few feet away from the venue. They were playing Van Morrison on the jukebox and had reasonably priced drink – beer and wine only though, which was a bit of a disappointment because by this point in the tour my tolerance to alcohol had ballooned so much as to make it necessary to consume the hard shit. You will, however, be glad to hear that I did not let this deter me in any way and enjoyed six drinks despite the two-drink-maximum liquor license.
The show itself was advertised as “everything free,” meaning admission, PBR and candy bars. I took advantage of the first two. There was no stage, just the bands on the same ground as the audience, each faction facing and feeding off the other. The Prayers and Tears played fabulously and were heckled by the drunken undergrads perfectly. A surprisingly large number of audience members kept yelling for songs about public transit. Good times were flowing.
The Mountain Goats started out their set surprisingly mellow for the free-show-and-free-beer crowd, with four of their first five songs being “Source Decay,” “Tallahassee,” “Cotton,” and “Love, Love, Love.” “Baboon” was also thrown in for the sole instance of the tour proper, and I will go out on a limb and state that the Dartmouth performance of “See America Right” was the best of the tour. Great show all around, the highlight perhaps being the point at which the crowd collectively urged Peter to “Drink, motherfucker! Drink!” It was an absolute shock when they did not return to the stage for a second encore, as I have perhaps never heard an audience futilely scream for more as I heard Hanover scream that night. After the show some dude was just holding his head and muttering “Oh my god! Oh my fucking god!” over and over for at least five minutes.
Alternate highlight: When someone yelled for John to “play whatever you want!” and he responded, “You know, when people say ‘play whatever you want,’ the stuff I really want to play I don’t know how to play. You know, like ‘2112’ by Rush. That would be awesome.” At which point Alex goes right into it. Beautiful.
Many folks found their way to the afterparty at the house of the guy who had booked the show and where, perhaps appropriately, the alcohol consisted solely of a case of store brand vodka. And I consider myself to be pretty up on store brand vodka but this stuff was so cheap even I had never laid eyes on it before. I would relay its name in order to advise all but the truly desperate to shy away, but my memory by that point in the evening remains spotty at best. And, finally, here let me here salute Alex Lazara, who was still firing on all cylinders at 4am when I left the party and with no less than four good-looking college chicks fawning over his every move. That man knows how to get things done.
October 27 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Remis Auditorium, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston MA
The Mountain Goats played great, opening with “Twin Human Highway Flares,” which is probably about as perfect an opener for a seated show as is humanly possible. Other than that, it was just a great set – a band on the last leg of the last tour of a very long year, flawlessly performing but coming off just a tad sterile in the vacuum of the MFA auditorium. But that makes the show sound boring – and it was a fabulous show, with probably the best performances all tour of many of the quieter numbers such as the afore mentioned opener, “Tallahassee” and “Shadow Song.” And it did have flat out more “Full Force Galesburg” tunes than any other show. And for the closing numbers David’s guitar was down in the mix and Alex’s keyboard up, making for an interesting listen. It was all just a bit generic. Maybe just because I was a little nervous about seeing the ex-girlfriend after the show. Maybe just because the last few shows had been so very raucous (in a good way) and I’d gotten pleasantly used to that. Maybe just because I hadn’t had anything to drink since 6pm.
October 26 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, The Winterpills – Iron Horse, Northampton MA
October 25 2005: Adam Sweeney – Club Passim, Cambridge MA
So that’s how I came to be here. And that’s about the whole story. Adam played and it was fun. He even had a new song about me and beer and rock and roll! How about that? And then I got a ride back to Northampton and a sofa for a couple of nights. Hell of a guy, that Adam Sweeney.
October 23 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Lunt Hall Basement, Haverford College, Haverford PA
The Prayers and Tears played well – and before the show I got to hear Alex explain to me this theory: Abortion = Murder according to the Christians, and Meat = Murder according to the Smiths; therefore Abortion = Meat, and fetuses should be sent to underdeveloped countries to feed the hungry. Made my whole night right there.
The Mountain Goats, upon entering the stage area, by which I refer to the five-inch raised section of the floor towards which the audience faced, were setting up their guitars when New Order’s “Temptation” came on over the PA. Peter later told me that it is perhaps his favorite song, ever. So Peter finishes setting up his bass and just starts right in, playing along with “Temptation” and nailing every little nuance of its bassline, almost as if he had played along with the record many, many times before. And as if that wasn’t amusing enough to watch on its own, once John got his guitar set up he started right in on the guitar part. So for about a minute and a half you’ve got the Mountain Goats up on stage playing along to the New Order record and looking like they’ve never had as good a time on stage in their whole lives. And then the show itself started. The fun just never stops. “Song for Dennis Brown” was breathtaking – easily its best performance all tour. And though “Pet Politics” had been played a few times before, Haverford marked its first full band performance.
And during the Prayers and Tears’ set Perry had broken a string on his Telecaster, which was David’s guitar-of-choice for their songs with the Mountain Goats, so he had to play the SG instead. Which fucking rocked. I thought so, I think most of the audience thought so, and after the show I overheard John telling David that he also thought so. And David didn’t touch the Telecaster for the rest of the tour. Due, I think, in no small part to the SG, the evening’s performance of “Oceanographer’s Choice” was easily the best of the tour. And due to the show actually being INSDIE the dorm, I didn’t even have to find a way into a building where I could sleep! Just waited for folks to clear out and then stretched out on a nice comfy easy chair for the night.
October 22 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Olde Club, Swarthmore College, Swarthmore PA
I recently wrote everyone I know an email informing them that we all, excepting our one friend who went to Swarthmore, went to the wrong damn college. Swarthmore was beautiful on every level. First, it is physically appealing to the eye. Old stone buildings, attractive co-eds, green grass (both kinds), etc. Second, they run their food service in an all-you-can-eat-so-long-as-you’re-on-the-meal-plan manner, and I found it remarkably easy to talk my way into the cafeteria despite not being on said meal-plan. And the show itself…..let us just say that MY college never sponsored a Mountain Goats show free of charge to all, much less sprang for all that free beer in the basement.
The show was typical of what you might expect, with a whole lot of undergrads there for the booze. There were a decent amount of folks there for the music though, and I thought it was a great show from the front of the stage but the Prayers and Tears who viewed the show from the back said it was pretty bad. Who knows, but I think they were sober so I’ll take their word for it. But I had a great time. John stopped in the middle of “Cotton” to call out some folks who were talking and was so amused by their response that he granted one of them a request. Namely, “Going to Georgia.” And after the show I just followed my ears to the dance music next door, where there was a huge party going on with more free beer. And the sofas in the multicultural center were comfy and abandoned and I slept great.
October 21 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Andy Warhol Museum, Pittsburgh PA
The songs the Mountain Goats played went, without exception, in reverse-chronological order from new to old. Old meaning they closed the set with “Solomon Revisited” off of the first fucking cassette. And they did “Palmcorder Yajna” all mellow like and threw in “The Alphonse Mambo.” Holy fuck, people, holy fuck. An encore without the Prayers and Tears rounded out the night. I’ve got a radio indeed.
October 20 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Uptown Theatre, Washington PA
The Washington show was in an old movie theatre that sells beer and liquor and popcorn in the back of the house and offers seats and tables all the way up to the very front of the stage, about a third of which were filled. Easily the most empty room of the tour, but a beautiful night from all angles. To start with, the Prayers and Tears played their best show all tour. Due to the sit-down nature of things and the presence of a baby grand on stage, they dropped their big rocker “Ammunition from a Bolt Action Heart” from the set and quieted down all the rest of their songs into one perfect, utterly sublime moment after another. And a power transformer blew just as the last notes of “Sad Lives of the Hollywood Lovers” faded into the woodwork, as if on cue. The Mountain Goats played yet another great set, throwing Tallahassee into the mix for the first time of the tour and doing “It Froze Me” for the first time since Urbana. Great show, got in for free again, and got a warm bed for the night. You just can’t beat that shit.
October 18 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, Vera – Buffalo Icon, Buffalo NY
October 17 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers – Lee’s Palace, Toronto ON
But the real crazy Toronto shit didn’t start until after the show when I went upstairs to brush my teeth. Lee’s has a pretty small bathroom, and a guy taking a piss looks at me and says, “Wow, times must be pretty rough, eh?” “What,” I counter, “You never seen a guy brushing his teeth at the rock club?” And he offers to buy me a beer when I’m done and that is not the type of offer I am in the habit of turning down. So he buys me a beer and we get to talking and then he buys me a few more and we head out to another bar where he buys approximately five pitchers for himself and his friends, of whom I am now a part. We run into the singer and guitarist for a local band (Therefore Peter John, they call themselves), and they take the opportunity to drunkenly run through a few of their numbers. To our drunken minds they are fabulous. And to their credit, I still get their song “One Way Ticket to London” stuck in my head despite only having heard it that one time. And when they finish up a nice young woman asks if she can play one, and we are drunk and she is a girl and so of course we oblige, and she plays one of the most beautiful tunes we have collectively ever heard. And when the bar closes the guy lets me sleep on his sofa, and it is a good night in Toronto.
October 15 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, Bellafea – Kraftbrau Brewery, Kalamazoo MI
And then to follow that right up the Kraftbrau served me the best beer of the trip! And lots of it! I can wholeheartedly recommend their Doppelboch, and it’s 8% to boot. And even further to boot, it was fucking cheap. I think I drank five or six of the things over the course of the night and my tab was only $14. And yet even MORE to boot: the promoter found out I was hitchhiking around and she let me stay at the bar during soundcheck and gave me a leftover poster advertising the show and didn’t make me pay the cover. To her!
The show was Bellafea’s last on the tour, so I picked up their 7” for a scant three dollars. The Mountain Goats again played with Franklin, and threw in the Silver Jews’ “Pet Politics” for the first time all tour. “Slow West Vultures” was also played. A great show, probably in the top 5 all tour.
But the fun did not end with the show! As I exited the Kraftbrau I said goodnight to Alex, who was talking to a couple of attractive young women. I thought nothing of this at the time, as Alex is a notoriously good-looking man and can often be found talking with attractive young women (they just won’t leave him alone!). And then maybe ten minutes later, as I stood outside the place asking everyone who came out if they were headed to Western Michigan U., and if so could I get a ride with them, Alex’s two girls come out and say of course I can get a ride with them. And I am seriously in debt to Alex because it seems that after I said hi to him, he told the girls that I was hitchhiking around and whatnot, and so these girls let me sleep on their sofa, gave me some leftover pizza, and in generally made a guy feel welcome. To Kalamazoo!
October 14 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, Bellafea – Empty Bottle, Chicago IL
But the soundcheck! I’m sure everyone at the show thought to themselves, Wow that’s a really good new song they played there. Lucky me being among the first people to hear it. But these people only think such thoughts because they don’t know that the band soundchecked the song (“Soil Babylon Springs”) multiple times and the first to hear it performed consisted of the bartender, assorted Prayers and Tears, assorted venue employees, and fuckin ME. And then the show itself ties with a Portland show I saw earlier that summer as Best Mountain Goats Show I’ve Ever Witnessed. The crowd was roaring after every song, and every song was amazing. A phenomenal take on Lion’s Teeth was performed with Franklin on keys again, and for the first time this tour the Prayers and Tears returned to the stage at the end of the evening, much to my relief, because I knew firsthand the combined power of the Mountain Goats and the Prayers and Tears, and I was really, really hoping that the first two shows were not to be indicative of the entire tour’s format. And the show fucking rocked. And the night was closed with John and Franklin doing “Memories” by Leonard Cohen. Fabulous.
And as an added bonus to the show I ran into this girl from Milwaukee who I keep running into at rock shows all over the place. First it was the Mountain Goats in New Orleans, followed by the Long Winters in Seattle, and now the Mountain Goats again in Chicago. Plus through the course of conversation we discovered that we have both spent a few nights on the very same sofa (Perry’s, to be precise). Always nice to converse with those of like mind. And further adding to the frenzy of the evening, Bellafea played again. And the Prayers and Tears pulled out “Raise Up You Celestial Choir” for the first time of the tour. I later heard through the rumor mill that David doesn’t like playing the song because he considers it their We’re Gonna Play This Now So You’ll Think We’re Good Even Though We Already Know We’re Good And We Shouldn’t Have To Prove It To Ignorant Shits Like You Song . Well, fuck him because I dig it and was glad to hear it played, no matter how ungroundbreaking it may be.
October 13 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, Bellafea – Open End Gallery, Chicago IL
Bellafea, from Chapel Hill, opened the show rather well. Very Rock + Roll, very screamy, and their set was bookended by two beautiflly quiet songs. The Prayers and Tears played well again, almost the exact set as in Urbana. The Mountain Goats this time played for an hour and brought Franklin Bruno to the stage for a few songs to close the night out. “Going to Cleveland” was played rather well, as was “Mole” with Franklin on keys. "No Children" was closed with and would not be touched again until Northampton.
After the show while waiting for the bus in front of the United Center, a few blocks south of the Open End, some cops stopped and one of them asked two of my fellow concert-goers and I just what in the hell we were doing, a bunch of white kids in this neighborhood. Waiting for the bus, we replied. The officer told us that we’d be wise to go somewhere else but it’s not like we had anywhere else to go, and then the bus appeared a few blocks away so the police bade us good day and moved on. It was my only exchange with the law all trip.
October 12 2005: The Mountain Goats, The Prayers and Tears of Arthur Digby Sellers, Beauty Shop – Canopy Club, Urbana IL
And the doors! They opened at eight! And I entered!
Sat through the very competent opener, locals known as Beauty Shop, with a very nice yet musically not-so-bright brother and sister. They had never heard of XTC, who were playing on the PA as we walked in. Then "Figure 8" was played, and it turned out they’d never heard of Elliott Smith. Then "The Soft Bulliten" was played and they collectively failed to identify artist and album, though to their credit they claimed to have "heard of" the Flaming Lips. But the sister was pretty good looking, so all was forgiven. The Prayers and Tears were up next, and they played well. It was nice to hear their live set since acquiring and listening to their record, something I had not experienced prior to Urbana.
And then John and Peter appeared on the stage. “What’s up Midwest? We’re the Mountain Goats!” and right into Broom People. Good times. The show was unique to the tour in many ways: It lasted no more than 45 minutes, no one besides John and Peter played, and many songs were played which were not touched for the rest of the year. “Neon Orange Glimmer Song” amongst them. That one made my day.